Contextualizing UNESCO’s Historic Urban Landscape Approach: A Framework for Identifying Modern Heritage in Post-Blast Beirut

Jala Makhzoumi, Howayda Al-Harithy, Mariam Bazzi - 21.12.2024

Abstract:

This paper reflects on the application and adaptation of the Historic Urban Landscape (HUL) approach in Beirut, Lebanon, in post-disaster conditions. Adopted by UNESCO in 2005, the HUL approach marked a shift in addressing urban heritage, echoing an evolution in theory. However, contextualizing the HUL approach to address distinct local, geographic, and cultural conditions and reframing its scale and scope of operation remains a challenge. This paper uses a case-study-based methodology as it reflects on the application of the Historic Urban Landscape approach in the post-blast context of Beirut. Commissioned by UNESCO, an interdisciplinary team at the Beirut Urban Lab used the HUL approach to identify modern heritage in Beirut after adapting it to the post-colonial and Mediterranean context of the city. This study contextualized modern heritage definitions, proposed a periodization of modern built and landscape heritage, and designated modern heritage based on its formal/spatial, urban/landscape, socio-cultural, and environmental values. This paper argues that the study contributes to the advancement of the Historic Urban Landscape approach by operationalizing it into an applicable heritage framework, employing a transdisciplinary model that involves local people at the institutional and community levels, and serving as a basis for generating conservation strategies responsive to place and culture. This study also pioneered a comprehensive, integrative, and transdisciplinary reading of modern heritage in Beirut, breaking the professional silos between disciplines and bringing landscape into the identification of heritage in Lebanon.

Read the full paper on the MDPI website.

Beirut’s Concentric Growth. Source: De Vaumas, Etienne. Le Relief de Beyrouth et son Influence sur le Développement de la Ville, Beirut. Publications Techniques et Scientifiques de L’Ecole Française d’Ingenieurs de Beyrouth, N. 11, 1946, reproduced by Beirut Urban Lab (2024)
Beirut’s Concentric Growth. Source: De Vaumas, Etienne. Le Relief de Beyrouth et son Influence sur le Développement de la Ville, Beirut. Publications Techniques et Scientifiques de L’Ecole Française d’Ingenieurs de Beyrouth, N. 11, 1946, reproduced by Beirut Urban Lab (2024)
Periodization of Modern Built Heritage. Source: Beirut Urban Lab (2021)
Periodization of Modern Built Heritage. Source: Beirut Urban Lab (2021)
Validating the Framework. (a) Team meeting with UNESCO and DGA representatives at DGA premises, (b) workshop with local and international experts at the American University of Beirut, (c) team members with citizen scientists on an urban walk in Gemmayzeh. Source: Beirut Urban Lab (2021)
Validating the Framework. (a) Team meeting with UNESCO and DGA representatives at DGA premises, (b) workshop with local and international experts at the American University of Beirut, (c) team members with citizen scientists on an urban walk in Gemmayzeh. Source: Beirut Urban Lab (2021)
Designation of Modern Built Heritage based on the team assessment. Source: Beirut Urban Lab (2021)
Designation of Modern Built Heritage based on the team assessment. Source: Beirut Urban Lab (2021)
Mapping of Building Clusters in solid colors and Garden Concentrations in green, outlined in black. Source: Beirut Urban Lab (2021)
Mapping of Building Clusters in solid colors and Garden Concentrations in green, outlined in black. Source: Beirut Urban Lab (2021)